Key facts
- AeroSpace's README describes it as an i3-like tiling window manager and says it will not require disabling SIP.
- SlidePane uses a scrolling strip and has a settings interface, shortcuts, profiles, and undo.
- AeroSpace is configured in a text file; SlidePane costs $29.99 once, with a 3-day trial.
- SlidePane requires macOS 13 or later and Apple silicon; one licence covers one Mac.
- We make SlidePane. AeroSpace claims below are based on its README, checked on 2026-11-12.
Two different ways to arrange windows
AeroSpace describes itself as an i3-like tiling window manager for macOS. Its README points users to a default TOML configuration and says that it will never require disabling System Integrity Protection. You can define bindings, layouts, and workspace behavior in that configuration. The project presents this file-based model as a fit for users comfortable editing text configuration. See the AeroSpace README, checked on 2026-11-12.
SlidePane does not use an i3 tree layout. Windows occupy positions along a scrolling strip. You move through the sequence and choose how wide each window should be, rather than fitting every open window into a fixed tiling arrangement. The app provides a Shortcuts pane, Profiles, and settings controls. The menu bar popover includes a live minimap, and Pause and restore windows returns surviving windows to their prior positions.
Both products need macOS permissions to move windows. Neither requires turning off SIP. The difference is how much configuration you want to author and whether the main mental model should be a set of tiling workspaces or a navigable line of windows.
Who should stay with AeroSpace
Stay with AeroSpace if you already have a working TOML setup, want to tune behavior through configuration, or prefer a tiling layout that makes the desktop a set of defined regions. It is also the natural fit if your muscle memory comes from i3-style keyboard workflows and you want to keep that model on macOS.
A text configuration is useful when you want changes in dotfiles and a reproducible setup. It also means the configuration file is part of the product experience. Read AeroSpace's own guide and README for current commands and settings rather than copying an old example. This article does not claim that one layout model is faster or more productive; the useful choice depends on your tasks and preferences.
When the scrolling strip fits better
Try SlidePane if you routinely keep more windows open than you want tiled at once, and would rather scroll to a window than shrink all windows to fit. A writing task might have a draft, source, notes, and a preview. Keep the draft and source at comfortable widths, then move along the strip as attention shifts.
You do not need to edit a configuration file to begin. Install the app, follow first run, grant Accessibility access, and use its Shortcuts settings to learn or change bindings. Start with one work task and a few windows. If two windows should share a position, inspect the app's stacks and tabs behavior. See the stacks and tabs guide for the available grouping model.
SlidePane is a paid app: $29.99 once, with a 3-day free trial. The licence works on one Mac at a time. It supports macOS 13 or later on Apple silicon, allows up to 7 days offline between licence checks, and has a 3-day refund window. No account is required. This is a different trade-off from AeroSpace's free, config-driven approach.
A careful side-by-side evaluation
Save your current AeroSpace configuration before experimenting. Quit or disable one manager before enabling the other so they do not both reposition the same windows. This is a practical precaution for any two tools that manage desktop windows.
Choose three apps from a normal task and keep the same display arrangement. In AeroSpace, note the layout and keybindings you use for those windows. In SlidePane, arrange the same windows on the strip, set readable widths, and try focus navigation. Ask whether you prefer predictable screen regions or a larger sequence that you can browse. Also check whether any app window behaves differently under either manager.
To verify the return path in SlidePane, choose Pause and restore windows from its menu bar controls. Management stops and surviving windows return to their original positions on connected displays. This provides a direct way to end the trial run and resume your previous setup. Do not assume a setting or shortcut has a direct equivalent across these apps; compare the actual action you want.
Which one should you choose?
Keep AeroSpace if its tiling model and TOML workflow already match how you work. Choose SlidePane if the scrolling strip makes it easier to keep windows readable and move among them without planning a grid. Both leave SIP on; that alone does not make their layouts interchangeable.
For more context, read the shortcuts guide, the profiles and undo guide, and the window rules guide.
Cite or share this page
Dapols. "AeroSpace vs SlidePane: no-SIP tiling or a scrolling strip." SlidePane, November 18, 2026. https://slidepane.com/en/blog/aerospace-vs-scrolling-strip
The link is stable. The citation uses the page's “Last updated” date.